8 Gluten-Free Cookies That Taste Like Oreos

For many years, the classic chocolate sandwich cookie was off-limits for individuals following a gluten-free diet. The iconic combination of rich chocolate wafers and sweet vanilla cream seemed like a distant memory for those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities. Back in 2013, when our family first embarked on a gluten-free journey, finding a suitable substitute for an Oreo-style cookie was virtually impossible. We truly missed this delightful treat, which is not only perfect for snacking but also a fundamental ingredient in countless dessert recipes, from Gluten-Free Oreo Pie Crust to indulgent ice cream pies and other sweet treats.

Thankfully, the landscape of gluten-free products has dramatically evolved. Today, the market is brimming with a fantastic array of delicious gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies, offering excellent alternatives for every palate. In this comprehensive guide, part of our Be A Better Baker series, we dive deep into the world of gluten-free Oreo alternatives. We’ll answer all your pressing questions, including:

• Does the original Oreo brand offer gluten-free versions?
• Which brands of chocolate sandwich cookies are certified gluten-free?
• Among the many options, which gluten-free Oreos truly taste the best?

From analyzing cost-effectiveness to evaluating taste, texture, and other pros and cons, here’s everything you need to know to find your perfect gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookie (and discover which ones are our absolute favorites).

Are Original Oreos Gluten-Free? Understanding Your Options

While Oreo itself has embraced the gluten-free market, they are certainly not the only player! Many other reputable brands have stepped up to offer their own delicious versions of gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies. Our taste test includes a comprehensive breakdown of 8 brands that are sure to satisfy your chocolate and cream cravings.

1. Oreo Gluten-Free Oreos (Our Favorite for Authentic Taste)

• COST: $3-5 per pack
• WHERE TO BUY: Target, Safeway, Walmart, most major grocery stores across the U.S., Vitacost
• ARE THEY VEGAN? While they contain no egg, dairy, or animal products, they are not officially certified vegan.
• TASTE NOTES: These cookies deliver all the classic texture and unmistakable flavor of the original Oreos. It’s genuinely difficult to tell the difference!

For years, Oreo fans on a gluten-free diet could only dream of enjoying their favorite cookie. That dream is now a delicious reality! The original chocolate sandwich cookie brand has introduced its own line of gluten-free Oreos, and we couldn’t be happier. Having lived a gluten-free life for over a decade without this option, the arrival of official gluten-free Oreos has been a game-changer. What’s truly remarkable is how perfectly they capture the iconic flavor and crisp texture of the classic cookie we all remember. The rich cocoa cookie and sweet vanilla creme are spot on, making them an instant favorite.

Oreo offers both standard gluten-free Oreos and Gluten-Free Double Stuf Oreos. Both varieties are incredibly satisfying, whether you’re enjoying them as a standalone snack, dunking them in milk, or incorporating them into your favorite gluten-free desserts. Their widespread availability in most grocery stores that stock regular Oreo products makes them a convenient and reliable choice for anyone needing a gluten-free option.

2. Kinnikinnick K-Toos (Allergen-Friendly & Versatile)

• COST: $4-6
• WHERE TO BUY: Kinnikinnick’s website, Amazon, Sprouts, Basha’s, Safeway, Albertson’s, Whole Foods, Vitacost
• ARE THEY VEGAN? Yes! Kinnikinnick K-Toos are certified vegan and dairy-free, making them an excellent choice for a wide range of dietary needs.
• TASTE TEST NOTES: These tend to be a little firmer than other brands. We often find them ideal for baking purposes rather than casual snacking.

Kinnikinnick KinniTOOS, or K-Toos as they are often called, are a highly reliable and versatile option for gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies. Beyond being gluten-free, they boast an impressive allergen-friendly profile, being free from dairy, nuts, eggs, soy, and peanuts. Their certified vegan status makes them a fantastic choice for those adhering to a vegan or egg-free diet, ensuring inclusivity for many dessert lovers.

Kinnikinnick is renowned for its wide range of gluten-free baked goods, including vanilla wafers, animal crackers, graham crackers, and more. Their K-Toos come in several exciting varieties, not just the classic chocolate with vanilla filling. You can find vanilla with vanilla filling, chocolate with chocolate filling, birthday cake, and even cinni-bun flavors. We’ve found that many of these unique flavors are even more delightful than their original chocolate version, offering a fun twist on the traditional sandwich cookie. While they might be slightly harder to locate than some mainstream brands, their commitment to taste and allergen-friendliness makes them well worth seeking out.

3. Glutino Chocolate Vanilla Creme Cookies (Rich & Creamy)

• COST: $5-6
• WHERE TO BUY: Glutino’s website, Sprouts, HEB, Kroger, Amazon, Safeway, Albertsons, Vitacost, Walmart
• ARE THEY VEGAN? These cookies do not list egg, dairy, or animal product ingredients, but they are not officially certified vegan.
• TASTE TEST NOTES: We were highly impressed by the smooth, rich vanilla flavor of the creme filling. These cookies were a definite highlight in our taste test!

Glutino is a brand many in the gluten-free community trust for a variety of products, including pretzels, animal crackers, and cereal bars. Their expertise extends beautifully to cookies, and their Chocolate Vanilla Creme Cookies are a testament to their quality. While they might be slightly less ubiquitous than the official Oreo brand, they confidently hold their own in terms of flavor and satisfaction. One of the standout features of Glutino’s offering is the exceptionally smooth and generously flavored creme center, which boasts a delightful vanilla essence that perfectly complements the chocolate wafer.

For those who love the extra indulgence of Oreo’s Double Stuf cookies, Glutino also offers an exciting alternative: their Super Stuffed Cookies. These are designed to provide an even greater creme-to-cookie ratio, catering to serious creme lovers. Glutino’s commitment to creating delicious and well-textured gluten-free treats makes their chocolate sandwich cookies a top contender for both snacking and incorporating into your favorite recipes.

4. Goodie Girl Chocolate Creme Cookies (Trendy & Vegan-Friendly)

• COST: $4-6
• WHERE TO BUY: Goodie Girl’s website, Whole Foods, Amazon
• ARE THEY VEGAN? YES! Goodie Girl recently reformulated their recipe, and the new version is certified vegan, making it an excellent choice for plant-based diets. The previous version did contain dairy, so always check the latest packaging!
• TASTE TEST NOTES: Goodie Girl is a really fun and innovative brand. While we tend to prefer some of their other sandwich cookie flavors, these chocolate creme cookies are a solid gluten-free Oreo-type option.

Goodie Girl has quickly become one of our favorite gluten-free brands, standing out with its playful branding and consistently delicious cookie offerings. Their rendition of gluten-free Oreo-style cookies is not only tasty but also incredibly accommodating for various dietary needs. These cookies are free from peanuts, eggs, dairy, and gluten, making them a superb and safe option for school lunches or households managing multiple allergies.

Beyond the classic chocolate creme, Goodie Girl excels in creating unique sandwich cookie experiences. They offer enticing flavors such as Birthday Cake and S’more. While we found the Birthday Cake flavor a bit subtle, the S’more cookies were a delightful hit! We’ve been particularly impressed by their other takes on famous cookies; their gluten-free mint cookies, for example, are remarkably similar in taste and texture to Girl Scout Thin Mints. Goodie Girl is a brand that consistently innovates and delivers on flavor, making their chocolate creme cookies a worthy contender in the gluten-free sandwich cookie market.

5. Great Value Gluten-Free Chocolate Creme Sandwich Cookies (Budget-Friendly for Baking)

• COST: ~$2.82
• WHERE TO BUY: Walmart(Online or In-Store)
• ARE THEY VEGAN? (Information not explicitly provided in original text, so keeping it blank.)
• TASTE TEST NOTES: While these are probably our least favorite for direct snacking due to a slightly less impactful texture and flavor, they perform exceptionally well when used in baking applications.

When budget is a primary concern, Walmart’s Great Value brand steps in with its incredibly affordable gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies. Priced at less than $3 a bag, these cookies are the most economical option on our list, and their wide availability in Walmart stores nationwide is another significant advantage. For casual snacking, we found the flavor to be a bit understated and the texture less satisfying compared to some of the other premium brands.

However, these cookies truly shine when incorporated into recipes. Their mild flavor means they won’t overpower other ingredients, and their ability to be crushed into crumbs makes them perfect for creating a gluten-free Oreo pie crust. If you’re looking for an inexpensive gluten-free cookie primarily for baking purposes, the Great Value option is a practical and accessible choice that delivers where it counts for dessert creation.

6. Simple Truth Gluten-Free Chocolate Flavored Sandwich Cookies (Clean Ingredients, Great Value)

• COST: $3-4
• WHERE TO BUY: Kroger family of stores (Fry’s, King Sooper’s, Ralph’s, Smith’s, etc.), Vitacost
• ARE THEY VEGAN? No. This brand uses egg white powder in its recipe.
• TASTE TEST NOTES: These cookies offer a great flavor profile and represent an excellent budget-friendly choice among the generic options.

Simple Truth, the popular store brand from the Kroger family of supermarkets, offers a noteworthy gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookie. A major appeal of Simple Truth products is their commitment to cleaner ingredients, meaning these cookies are made without artificial dyes, colors, or flavors. Furthermore, they are produced in a peanut-free facility, making them a safe and thoughtful option for school environments or for individuals with peanut allergies.

In our taste test, these budget-friendly cookies emerged as our favorite generic brand, trailing only behind Trader Joe’s. They strike a pleasant balance, offering crisp, creme-filled cookies with a satisfying chocolate flavor. For their price point and ingredient quality, Simple Truth’s gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies are a consistently solid choice that delivers on taste and accessibility. If you’re shopping at a Kroger-affiliated store, these are definitely worth picking up.

7. Trader Joe’s Gluten-Free Joe-Joe’s (Our Runner-Up Favorite with a New Recipe)

• COST: ~$3
• WHERE TO BUY: Exclusively at Trader Joe’s stores
• ARE THEY VEGAN? No. This brand uses egg in its recipe.
• TASTE TEST NOTES: These are our second favorite, only *barely* behind the official Oreo brand. Their recent reformulation truly hits all the right notes for an exceptional cookie experience!

The introduction of gluten-free Joe-Joe’s at Trader Joe’s was met with much enthusiasm, and for good reason! Trader Joe’s has long been celebrated for its unique and affordable products, and their take on the classic chocolate sandwich cookie has been a consistent fan favorite within the gluten-free community. What’s particularly exciting is that Trader Joe’s just reformulated these cookies in June 2022, and the new recipe is even better than the last, elevating the Joe-Joe’s experience to new heights.

The updated formulation boasts a wonderfully crispy cookie texture, delivering a satisfying crunch with every bite. The chocolate flavor of the wafers is rich and pronounced, perfectly balanced by a smooth, creamy vanilla center. These cookies are absolutely delicious, whether enjoyed on their own, with a glass of milk, or as part of a dessert. While their regular gluten-free Joe-Joe’s are already a delight, keep a special eye out for their highly anticipated holiday gluten-free Peppermint Joe-Joe’s, which typically appear on shelves from November to December. These seasonal treats are a must-try for mint-chocolate lovers!

8. Mi-Del Gluten-Free Chocolate Sandwich Cookies (Best for Crumb Crusts)

• COST: ~$3
• WHERE TO BUY: Mi-Del’s website, Amazon, occasionally in specialty grocery stores
• ARE THEY VEGAN? Mi-Del’s recipe includes no animal, egg, or dairy products, but they are not listed as certified vegan.
• TASTE TEST NOTES: These cookies tend to be quite crumbly and lighter in flavor compared to others, making them less ideal for direct snacking but excellent for making dessert crusts.

Mi-Del gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies can sometimes be a bit more challenging to find in conventional grocery stores, often requiring a visit to a natural foods market or an online order. In terms of texture for snacking, we find them to be a bit crumbly and somewhat lacking in a bold, rich flavor that other brands offer. This makes them a less preferred choice for simply eating out of the bag.

However, what might be a drawback for snacking becomes a distinct advantage for baking! Their slightly drier, crumbly texture makes them incredibly easy to process into fine crumbs, which are absolutely perfect for creating a firm and flavorful gluten-free Oreo pie crust or other baked treats that call for a cookie base. Mi-Del offers these gluten-free sandwich cookies in both chocolate and royal vanilla flavors, and both varieties are peanut-free, ensuring they are a safe option for schools and families managing peanut allergies.

FAQ: Your Questions About Gluten-Free Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Answered

Are Original Oreos Gluten-Free? No, traditional Oreos are made with wheat flour and are not gluten-free. However, the good news is that Oreo now produces dedicated Gluten-Free Oreos and Gluten-Free Double-Stuf Oreos. Always look for the specific gluten-free packaging to ensure you’re choosing the correct product.

Are Gluten-Free Oreos Safe For Celiacs? Yes, the certified gluten-free versions of Oreo and other brands are safe for individuals with celiac disease, gluten intolerance, or those following a strict gluten-free diet. It is crucial to always purchase products explicitly labeled “gluten-free” to avoid cross-contamination and ensure safety. Original Oreos are not suitable for those with celiac disease.

What Are The Best Gluten-Free Chocolate Sandwich Cookies? For enjoying as a standalone snack, our top two favorites are the official Oreo Gluten-Free Oreos for their authentic taste, closely followed by Trader Joe’s Gluten-Free Joe-Joe’s thanks to their improved recipe. Glutino and Simple Truth brands also offer excellent flavor and texture for snacking. When it comes to baking, particularly for creating a gluten-free Oreo pie crust, all of these brands work wonderfully, with Mi-Del and Great Value being particularly effective due to their crumbly texture and affordability.

Can You Make Homemade Gluten-Free Oreos? Absolutely! While store-bought options offer convenience, making your own gluten-free Oreos can be a fun and rewarding project. However, we generally don’t recommend homemade versions for recipes like Oreo crusts, as their texture might not hold up as well as commercial brands. For a delightful homemade treat, we particularly enjoy this recipe from Snixy Kitchen, which even offers vanilla and peppermint variations!

What Should I Look For When Buying Gluten-Free Chocolate Sandwich Cookies? When selecting gluten-free sandwich cookies, always check for “gluten-free” certification on the packaging. Consider your dietary needs: some brands are also vegan, dairy-free, or nut-free. Read ingredient lists carefully to avoid hidden allergens. Finally, decide if you’ll be primarily snacking or baking; some cookies are better suited for one purpose over the other.

Delicious Gluten-Free Oreo Desserts To Try:

• Gluten-Free Oreo Pie Crust
• Gluten-Free Oreo Cheesecake
• Gluten-Free Oreo Brownies
• Gluten-Free Grasshopper Ice Cream Pie
• Gluten-Free No-Bake Chocolate Cheesecake
• Gluten-Free Chocolate Pie
• Gluten-Free Chocolate Cookies And Cream Cookies